Renegade CCCBCA All-Americans
| Year | Name | Position |
| 1997 | KYLE URSERY | OUTFIELD |
| 1998 | ANTHONY ACEVEDO | OUTFIELD |
| 1999 | OCTAVIO MARTINEZ | CATCHER |
| 2006 | MANNY MCELROY | PITCHER |
| 2006 | KYLE MORGAN | OUTFIELD |
| 2006 | JUAN MARTINEZ | SHORTSTOP |
| 2008 | KYLE WITTEN | PITCHER |
| 2008 | BRANDON BOREN | SECOND BASE |
| 2008 | CASEY BROWN | OUTFIELD |
| 2009 | JARRET MARTIN | DESIGNATED HITTER |
| 2010 | DYLAN NASIATKA | CATCHER |
| 2012 | TYLER PAINTON | PITCHER |
| 2013 | KYLE NIXON | OUTFIELD |
Renegade ABCA/Rawlings All-Americans
| Year | Name | Position |
| 2010 | DYLAN NASIATKA | CATCHER |
| 2012 | TYLER PAINTON | PITCHER |
| 2013 | KYLE NIXON | OUTFIELD |